Vinyl Record Grading Guide

Vinyl Record Grading Guide


Understanding Record and Cover Conditions

When buying, selling or valuing collectible vinyl records, condition matters. A record's grade describes the physical condition of the disc, while a separate cover grade describes the sleeve and packaging. Even copies of the same release can sell for very different prices depending on their condition.

Two widely used grading conventions are the US Goldmine system and the UK Record Collector system. The comparison below helps you understand commonly used grades, but it is not an official conversion between the systems.

Jump to: Record condition · Cover condition · Condition and value

Two widely used vinyl grading systems are the US Goldmine system and the UK Record Collector system. Their grades are not directly interchangeable. The rows below provide an approximate comparison, not an official conversion.

Record Condition – US vs. UK

US – GoldmineUK – Record CollectorUS descriptionUK description
MMintMMintPerfect in every respect; exceptionally rare and should be assigned only when the condition is beyond dispute.Brand-new condition, no surface marks or deterioration in sound quality. Sealed or unplayed copies should be Mint.
NM / M−Near MintNM / M−Near MintAlmost flawless, glossy, with no visible defects, spindle marks or surface noise. A carefully played record may still qualify.
VG+ / EVery Good PlusEXExcellentLight scuffs, faint scratches or minor handling marks are acceptable, provided they do not affect playback.Some evidence of play, but very little reduction in sound quality.
VG / VG−Very GoodVGVery GoodObvious wear, reduced gloss and audible surface noise or scratches, particularly in quiet passages, without overpowering the music.Clearly played many times, with noticeable surface marks and occasional light scratches, but no major deterioration in sound quality.
GGoodGGoodSignificant groove wear and surface noise, but the record should play through without skipping.Noticeably deteriorated sound, possibly with distortion and scratches.
FFairFFairVery poor condition; the disc may be cracked, badly warped, or skip or repeat during playback.Barely playable, with considerable surface noise; it may jump.
PPoorPPoorSeverely damaged; may be cracked, impossibly warped, or unable to play correctly.Will not play properly because of scratches, heavy surface noise or other defects.

Cover Condition – US vs. UK

US – GoldmineUK – Record CollectorUS descriptionUK description
MMintMMintAbsolutely perfect sleeve, with no flaws.Cover and any inserts, booklets or posters are in perfect condition.
NM / M−Near MintNM / M−Near MintNo creases, ring wear, seam splits, writing or other visible defects.
VG+ / EVery Good PlusEXExcellentOnly minor wear; a tiny bottom seam split or a cut-out mark may be present. A cut-out cannot be Near Mint.Slight wear and/or creasing may be present.
VG / VG−Very GoodVGVery GoodNoticeable ring wear, creases, writing, stamps or seam splits may be present.Normal wear and tear is acceptable, without major defects.
GGoodGGoodDistracting ring wear, obvious seam splits, substantial writing or other significant damage.Folding, scuffed edges, spine splits, discolouration and similar wear.
FFairFFairVery heavily damaged sleeve; condition may be severely compromised.Torn, stained and/or defaced cover and contents.
PPoorPPoorExtremely damaged sleeve, potentially barely usable.Badly damaged or partly missing cover and contents.

Important: US VG+ is broadly comparable to UK EX, but identical grade abbreviations (such as VG) do not necessarily indicate identical standards.

Sources: US Goldmine grading descriptions (summarised); UK Record Collector Magazine / Rare Record Price Guide (summarised).

How Condition Affects Vinyl Record Value

Condition is one of several factors that influence the price of a collectible record. Collectors generally pay more for well-preserved copies, especially when the record plays cleanly and the original sleeve is in good shape. However, there is no universal percentage difference between grades.

Before comparing sale prices, identify the correct release. The artist and album title alone are not enough: country, year, label, catalogue number, pressing variation and whether a copy is an original pressing or reissue can all affect value.

popsike.com provides an archive of historical completed vinyl sales. Search for your record and compare similar pressings in similar condition, rather than relying on a single high or low sale price.

Illustrative relative vinyl record values by condition: Mint 100%, Excellent 80%, Very Good 50%, Good 30%, Fair 15%, Poor 8%.
Illustrative relative values based on condition. Actual market prices may vary significantly depending on pressing, rarity and demand.

Search historical vinyl record prices on popsike.com