Beatles - Yesterday & Today * 2nd State Butcher Cover * NM * US MONO 1st PRESS
  £   1,951
  $   2,329


£ 1951 Sold For
Mar 13, 2024 Sold Date
Mar 3, 2024 Start Date
42   Number Of Bids
  Great Britain Country Of Seller
eBay Auctioned at
save auction  


The Beatles - Yesterday & Today * 2nd State Butcher Cover * NM! * US MONO 1st PRESS *


Brief Summary

  • Extremely rare 2nd State butcher sleeve
  • EX+ audio; MINT labels; MINT- vinyl surface
  • EX sleeve in shrink!
  • Capitol US 'rainbow' perimeter labels
  • Original Capitol advertising inner sleeve 

More details, including a comprehensive condition report and a full audio recording, can be found in the description below.

Album Background

Released in June of 1966, Yesterday and Today is the 12th American-released album by The Beatles. Much like all other Capitol Records releases, the album was an amalgamation of tracks that hadn’t featured on a US LP to date; with inclusions from Help!, Rubber Soul, and Revolver. However, it is the cover art, rather than the music, that the album is famous for. Known as the ‘Butcher Cover’, the original album art featured an image of the Beatles dressed in white coats, covered with decapitated baby dolls and pieces of meat. Although several opposing views have been put forward, the band members insist that the artwork was a protest against the Vietnam war. In response to retailers' concern over the gory image, Capitol immediately withdrew the LP and replaced the cover art with a shot of the band posed around a steamer trunk.


Rather than throwing away the ‘butcher’ sleeves, the sleeve manufactures pasted the new ‘trunk’ image on top of the original cover art. For sale in this listing is one such sleeve. Remarkably, it still maintains the original shrink wrap. Known as the ‘second state’ variant, they are becoming increasingly rare as collectors continue to remove the paste-over image in the hope of revealing the highly collectible butcher cover. In addition to featuring this rare sleeve variant, the album comes with superb mint- mono disc that offer superb audio reproduction.

Pressing & Variant Information

Catalogue number: T 2553


Matrix number: T - 1 - 2553 - G22 * / T - 2 - 2553 - G22 *


Vinyl Weight: 156g

Pressing Information:


The hand etched matrix numbers and stamped asterisk symbol confirm that the record was produced in the LA factory. 


Label Information:


The Capitol Records labels are the first West Coast variant that were produced by Bert-Co Enterprises in Los Angeles. Several notable features identify this. They are:

  1. The black background with centred Capitol logo and rainbow perimeter;
  2. The catalogue number is right-aligned; and
  3. All tracks publishers credits are given to the Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI).

Sleeve Information:


The non-laminated sleeve is a ‘second state’ variant produced by Imperial Packing Co. Inc., Indiana for the LA capitol factory. Several notable features identify this variant. They are:

  1. The paste over ‘trunk’ cover image. Evidence of the butcher cover underneath can be seen on the bottom edge, the bottom right-hand corner, and approximately 10cm from the bottom on the right-hand side where the ‘V’ of Ringo’s black V-neck sweatshirt can be seen;
  2. The number ‘6’ printed next to the RIAA logo on the rear; and
  3. The half-hidden text, “File Under: The Beatles”, to the top right-hand corner on the front side.

Inner Sleeve & Extras:


The album is complete with the original Capitol Records advertising inner sleeve.

Condition Report

Disc: MINT -

Labels: MINT 


The labels are bright, clean and retain rich, vibrant colours. No spindle trails are visible around each unworn centre hole.

Visual: MINT - 


The vinyl retains the original superb deep gloss playing surfaces that appear blemish free in bright daylight. Under the glare of a halogen desk lamp feint paper hairlines can be seen to both sides alongside an iridescent rainbow shine.

Sound Quality: MINT -


I have included complete audio recordings to enable you to judge the quality of the audio reproduction yourself. If you are having problems playing the clips please get in touch. 

Side 1:  



Side 2: 



As can be heard in the recordings, the audio is superb. As with most Capitol pressings from the mid-60s (at least the copies I have heard), light-static can be heard during the dead-wax but nothing that is distracting or that bleeds into the main body of the audio. Very difficult to improve upon.



I’m somewhat torn on the grading of the sleeve. Ostensibly, the sleeve is in excellent/excellent+ condition. It still has the original shrink wrap in place; both the front and rear are without discolouration; the spine, opening and top and bottom edges are without wear; the corners are all strong etc. However, at some stage a previous owner made the decision to attempt a DIY 'third' state conversion. The Butcher sleeve is now visible on two areas on the right-hand side. Both peels are neat. Personally, I quite like the affec, I know others might not.


Inner Sleeve: EXCELLENT


The original inner sleeve is in great condition. It is very clean and displays only mild creasing.

Additional InfoGrading StandardShipping & ReturnsGlossary of Terms

All discs are cleaned using dedicated ultra-sonic and vacuum cleaners. We use a novel four-step approach. More information on the process can be found here. 


Audio testing and recording is performed on a Technics SL-1200 G turntable fitted with a Nagaoka MP-500 stylus. 


After the audio test, each disc is placed within a brand-new mobile fidelity inner sleeve. The disc, sleeve, and any additional inserts are then placed inside a 4mm polypropylene outer sleeve.  


To protect the integrity of our listings, we ask that all individuals with less than 10 feedback get in touch prior to placing a bid. If this is not performed your bid will be cancelled. 



Vinyl record grading is, by it's very nature, extremely subjective. A globally accepted grading standard is yet to emerge. Because of this, differences between a sellers grade and a buyers expectation are still common. As collectors ourselves, we grew tired of receiving records that simply were not as described. How can a record be 'mint' if it has a skip and looks like my cat had a disco on it? Incredibly, some records are 'graded' without an audio test being performed. Consequently, purchasing vinyl records online can be extremely disappointing. 


We decided to do things differently. All of our listings include a detailed and objective condition report, a comprehensive selection of high-quality photographs, and a complete high-fidelity audio recording. In doing so, we hope to enable any potential buyer to make an informed evaluation of the condition of each item themself.  


That being said, we do pride ourselves in preparing and grading vinyl records to the highest possible standards. Here is our process:

  • Prior to grading both the vinyl and sleeve are cautiously but thoroughly cleaned.
  • All items of the album are inspected in both bright daylight and underneath a halogen desk lamp. Any defects are noted.
  • The vinyl is played through on our high-end system at volume. The entire record is listened to and recorded. Any defects are noted.
  • We evaluate each aspect of the album with respect to the grading table as set out below. 


Dissatisfied by ambiguity in well-established grading standards, we decided to create our own. Drawing inspiration from existing grading standards, constructive feedback from a global customer base, and the vast experience of friends and colleagues in the industry, we crafted a meticulous and comprehensive standard. For brevity, a shortened version is provided below. The full Blue Chip Vinyl Standard will be published and available on our soon to be finished website. Updates to follow. 



The Blue Chip Vinyl Standard





The MINT (M) classification refers to an item that is perfect in every way. It is extremely rare that a used or unsealed vinyl record will meet the necessary criteria. In fact, many brand new items do not. 


The Disc:

The labels will be bright and clean. There will be no spindle marks and no wear to the centre hole. The centre of the label and the centre of the disc will be perfectly aligned. The vinyl surface will display an iridescent lustre. No surface marks are visible. The audio is clear and precise. The only surface noise present is the sound of the interaction with the stylus. 


The Sleeve:

The cover art will be vibrant. Any printed text will be clear and without smudging. There will be no staining. The corners, the spine, and all other edges will be without wear. The laminate has no creases, bubbles or ripples. Period original point-of-sale price and shop advertisement stickers are permitted.


The Inserts:

Any original additional inserts, such as an inner sleeve, lyric sheet, booklet or poster, are included and in perfect condition.




An accurate description of an EXCELLENT (EX) vinyl record is: "from a distance it looks mint". Upon closer inspection, however, several minor flaws will be evident. Only a small percentage of used vinyl records fall into this classification. As such, an EX record will be considered a final upgrade for the majority of collectors. In fact, some even prefer purchasing items in excellent condition to mint as they still look and sound exceptional, but the visible signs of use add character and authenticity. 


The Disc:

The labels will be bright and clean with no writing or stickers present. A small number of spindle marks will be visible. Slight misalignment between the label and disc centres may be evident. The vinyl surface will retain the original lustre but light, non-feel-able marks will be present. Quiet surface noise will be audible during the lead-ins, dead wax and quieter sections, although it will never distract. There will be no lessening in the sound quality of the actual audio reproduction. 


The Sleeve:

Not all, but some of the following defects will be present: minor rubbing/discolouration to the cover art and printed text; small, light stains/handling marks; corner softening; minor rubbing/wear to the spine and edges; short laminate ripples. Unless otherwise flawless, neither writing nor seam splits are permissible. 

The Inserts:

Any original inserts, such as an inner sleeve, lyric sheet, booklet or poster are included and show only minor deterioration in condition.


Very Good:


A VERY GOOD (VG) vinyl record will display obvious signs of prior handling and use but is still visually presentable and very useable. 


The Disc:

The defects as set out above for an EX classification above will be more pronounced and/or more numerous. Several additional defects may be present. A neatly written or a non-original sticker may be present one or both labels. An increased number of surface marks will be visible including some which can be felt. Pops and clicks will be audible. One or two may repeat for a small number of revolutions. Groove wear distortion may be audible during the introduction or for a short section during the remainder of the recording. Skips and sticks are not permissible. 


The Sleeve:

The defects as set out above for an EX classification above will be more pronounced and/or more numerous. Several additional defects may be present: neat writing; a non-original sticker; minor creases, especially near corners; small areas of laminate lift; import/export cut-out holes. 


The Inserts:

The original inner sleeve will be present and will still be capable of holding a record securely. Discolouration, minor seam splits, creasing and writing may be present. If additional inserts were originally included, some, if not all, will not be present. 


It is extremely rare that all aspects of a vinyl record  will be accurately described by a single grading classification. To all for circumstances when an item does not, a plus or minus will be added to the grading classification. For example, if the majority of the audio plays EX but a small number of tracks are M, an EX+ will be used. If, instead, a small number of tracks play VG, an EX- classification will be used. 



We worked hard to find a shipping solution that is appropriate for the Blue Chip items that we sell. Nearly 500 records later we are yet to have any shipping related damage reported. All of our items are sent with full-value insurance and are packed and shipped within 24hrs of purchase.


To protect your record during transit we use high quality, double-walled corrugated cardboard vinyl mailers with each and every order. Additional cardboard stiffeners are used when appropriate and required. The disc, sleeve, and any inserts are all housed inside a high-density polypropylene outer sleeve. And yes, before you ask, the disc is housed outside of the sleeve. 


Royal Mail Special Delivery Guaranted By 1pm is our preferred shipping partner for all UK orders. No fee is charged for this service. 


eBay's Global Shipping Programme is utilised for all international orders. Through experience, I have found this to be the quickest, most reliable, and most comprehensive service. eBay manage all aspects; pricing, invoicing and fee collection. When more than one item is purchased, the shipping cost is combined and spread across each item individually. Shipping occurs as follows:


  1. We pack and ship the item from our location to eBay's global delivery partner, Geodis. To reflect our UK shipping policy, we do not charge for this service. 
  2. We upload a tracking reference number. Tracking updates can be viewed on the relevant order details page on eBay or alternatively on you can visit Royal Mail's website. 
  3. Geodis accept the item at their UK distribution centre. They manage all aspects of the shipment from here.
  4. A second tracking number will be provided by Geodis. Regular tracking updates will be provided on the relevant order details page. 


For buyers in the EU, North America and Australasia we are also able to offer direct shipping through a third party in certain cases. Please get in touch prior to bidding to discuss this. 


Please contact us if there is a problem with your purchase and we will work with you to find a resolution. 



There are several terms that we frequently use in our listings that may be unfamiliar to some. To help define these terms, we will first outline the way in which vintage vinyl records were produced.

  1. The original audio was recorded on tape.
  2. A lacquer engineer used this to produce a lacquer plate. This is also referred to as the father plate. 
  3. The lacquer plate was used to produce a mother plate.
  4. A mother plate was then used to produce a stamper plate.
  5. A stamper plate was subsequently used to press a record. 


The matrix number identifies which lacquer plate was used. It is usually a catalogue number followed by a number/letter combination


The mother code identifies which mother plate was used. It is usually a number


The stamper code identifies which stamper plate was used. It is usually a codified letter. Each record company uses a different code. For example, EMI used GRAMPHLTD where G=1, R=2 etc. 


All of this information can be usually be found on the central dead-wax of each disc. Sometimes additional information, such as a signature from the lacquer engineer, can be found here too. 


Through use, the stamper, mother, and lacquer plates all become worn. Consequently, the quality of the audio reproduction deteriorates. This is why first pressings with early mother & stamper codes are so highly prized by audiophile collectors. Although exacts figures are unknown, it is thought that each stamper produced ~1000 records, each mother ~100 stampers, and each lacquer ~15 mothers. 


We are sometimes questioned regarding our use of the terms 'pressing' and 'variant'. These terms are often used interchangeably which we believe is incorrect.


We use the term pressing to refer exclusively to the lacquer plate that was used to produce the disc. If the first lacquer plate was used, the disc is a first press. The second lacquer plate, a second press and so on.


We use the term variant to distinguish between differences in design introduced during the production process. 


A crossover pressing, or, equally, a crossover variant, refers to an item in which more than one pressing/variant are present on a single vinyl record. 


We make this distinction as it is not always the case that discs with first variant labels were produced before discs with second variant labels. We have seen countless examples where the mother and stamper codes confirm this. We believe, therefor, that it is misleading to conflate the terms as it always suggests that a disc with a first variant label was produced before the equivalent record with second variant label. 

We hope you will love your purchase, however if you need to return it, we have a 60 day return policy.

We hope you will love your purchase, however if you need to return it, we have a 60 day return policy.

We hope you will love your purchase, however if you need to return it, we have a 60 day return policy.

We hope you will love your purchase, however if you need to return it, we have a 60 day return policy.

Got a question about this item? We'd love to help. Click here to get in touch.  

Other Services

Vinyl Cleaning

Tired of annoying dust crackle spoiling your favourite vinyl? We have a solution: our  market leading vinyl cleaning service. For more information and pricing, click here.

Vinyl Flattening

Own a vinyl record with an edge or dish warp? We have invested in state of the art technology that repairs vinyl safely and effectively. For more information and pricing, click here. 


Do you have vinyl records that you are interested in selling? Whether you require a valuation, a direct sale or a consignment service we can help. To discuss this with us further, click here.


Interested in investing in vinyl records? Whether it's a single hard-to-get item or an entire collection, we can help. To discuss this with us further, click here.

You May Also Like 

The Beatles - Please Please Me: * BLACK & GOLD LABELS * STEREO * DICK JAMES Publisher Credit * RARE STAMPERS *

Starting Bid: £34.99

Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon: * Solid Blue Triangle Labels * A2/B2 Matrix Numbers * Complete!* UK 1st Pressing 

Starting Bid: £34.99

The Beatles - Please Please Me: * BLACK & GOLD LABELS * MONO * NORTHERN SONGS Publisher Credit * EARLY STAMPERS *

Starting Bid: £34.99

Nick Drake - Five Leaves Left: * SUPERB MINT- AUDIO! * MISPRINT SLEEVE * A2/B2 MATRIX NUMBERS * UK 1st Press *

Starting Price: £34.99

View All Items For Sale  

price rating